Court for Custody Essay - 723 Words

| Court for Custody | | | Amy Burnside | 3/10/2013 | | A married couple, both addicted to drugs, is unable to care for their infant daughter. She is taken from them by court order and placed in a foster home. The years pass. She comes to regard her foster parents as her real parents. They love her as they would their own daughter. When the child is 9 yrs. old, the natural parents, rehabilitated from drugs, begin court action to regain custody. The case is decided in their favor. The child is returned to them, against her will. The two of the Three Primary Schools of Ethics that this dilemma is Ends Based Ethics and Rule Based Ethics. I am going to discuss the similarities and differences in Ends Based Ethics†¦show more content†¦The other thing that is right in some ways is when the court gave the little girl back to the real parents, but it is also wrong because the little girl did not want to go back to her parents because she was with the foster parents since she was an infant. So it is going to be hard on the little girl to get to know her real parents when she was with the foster parents for 9 years. The differences in this dilemma for Ends Based and Rule Based Ethics are right or wrong, fear of the laws, and codes. The wrong within this dilemma are how the court gives the little girl back to the real parents after they have not been her life for 9 years, how the real parents should of get off of drugs before their daughter turn 9 years old, and how the court made the little girl go with her real parents. The fear of the law within this dilemma are how the courts does not listen to the little girl, how the courts took the little girl from the real parents, and how long the courts let the real parents go to long before they try to get their daughter back. The codes within this dilemma are how the real parents can’t care for the little girl, how the foster parents can take care of the child better than the real parents, and how the courts fellows the laws. I do agree thatShow MoreRelatedCusto dy Court : The Custody855 Words   |  4 Pages Custody Court I decided to go through the courts to determine custody because of several reasons. The first reason was because my son’s father was on the birth certificate and, the police stated that if he took my son from me, it would be considered kidnapping. So, it was in essence to protect my son first. Secondly, it was part of the process of getting child support as well as my restraining order. The restraining order was done through the civil courts and, the originally gave me fullRead MoreSentencing Courts Have Given Enhanced Credit For Time Spent On Pre Custody1411 Words   |  6 PagesFacts In the past, sentencing courts have given enhanced credit for time-spent in pre-custody, which is usually at a rate of two days for every day of detention, however, â€Å"enhanced credit is not available if the person was denied bail primarily because of a prior conviction† (R. v. Safarzadeh‑Markhali, 2016 SCC 14 (CanLII)). In November 2010, Hamidreza Safarzadeh-Markhali â€Å"was arrested and charged with several offences† (R. v. Safarzadeh‑Markhali, 2016 SCC 14 (CanLII), par. 4). The bail judge madeRead MoreDiscussion. In Order For Nonparents To Gain Custody Of1109 Words   |  5 PagesDiscussion In order for nonparents to gain custody of children, they must establish a child-parent relationship; they must be able to rebut the presumption that the legal parent acts in the best interest of the child. Or.Rev.Stat.  §109.119 (2015). The nonparents can rebut this presumption by proving that the legal parent is either unwilling or unable to care for their child. Id. The petitioner for custody is or has been the child’s primary caretaker. Id. If relief is denied the circumstances willRead MoreLegal Writing Graded Project 2 - Petitioner1229 Words   |  5 Pages MEMORANDUM JOHN BRIGHT RESPONDENT Comes Petitioner, by counsel, and for her Memorandum states as follows: I. FACTS Sally Bright (Petitioner), filed for divorce and custody of 14 year old daughter, Chastity. John Bright (Respondent) also requested custody. The court ordered temporary custody of the minor child to Petitioner and visitation with Respondent every weekend. Petitioner will be moving to another part of the country to take a job. Respondent has realized he is gayRead MoreFamily Law Is An Area That Concern About Legal Issues Involving1283 Words   |  6 Pages Family law is an area that concern about legal issues involving family relationships, such as marriage, divorce, adoption and child custody. Every country has its own family law and its typically influences by the issue, culture and religion in that country. In Malaysia, family law is divided into two categories; Islamic Family Law (Federal Territories) and the Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce). Malaysia is an Islamic country. Hence, this family law distinguishes between Muslims and non-MuslimsRead MoreForensic Psychology And The Justice System1222 Words   |  5 Pagesevaluations that the forensic psychologist do is in Child custody. (Freedheim Weiner 2003). A Child custody evaluation is one the most complex and challenging evaluation in which forensic psychologist assess the parents and children. During custody dispute evaluators are required to assess multiple people such as parents, children, parents’ significant others. The child custody evaluations provide the court with information regarding what custody and visitation arrangement will be in favor of the childRead MoreFathers Should Not Be Treated1417 Words   |  6 PagesFathers Should Not Be Treated the Same as Mothers in Deciding Family Court Cases Involving Child Custody A major argument in contemporary debates on social issues is that mothers are often favored in family court decisions. This favoritism is claimed to be particularly rampant on the issue of children’s custody, whereby many cases grant the custody to mothers. Here, the â€Å"nurturing† stereotype that perceives a mother as a better nurturer is blamed for the cases’ outcome. A recent study on whetherRead MoreNegative Effects Of Guardianship1745 Words   |  7 Pagesand child. Specific Population Impacted There are several populations impacted by guardianship. The most vulnerable population is the children themselves. Children are impacted because they are being taken out of their parent’s custody and being putting in the custody of a third party. The biological parents are impacted because they are no longer the primary caregivers to their children. Parents are not able to see children without an agreement with all parties which include guardian ad litemRead MoreYouth Criminal Justice Act1532 Words   |  7 PagesCriminal Justice Act is protection of the public through crime prevention, rehabilitation, and meaningful consequences (s.3(1)(a)(I-iii)). For a better understanding on whether the courts were following the Youth Criminal Justice Acts principles in practice, I went to Edmonton Law Courts and sat in on youth court. After reviewing the act in theory and practice, I argue that the Youth Criminal Justice Act is doing a fair job in fulfilling its purpose, but does need some improvements. The YouthRead MoreThe Debate On Marriage And Parenting Rights For Gay And1673 Words   |  7 Pagesthat the state has a right to favor heterosexual norms. However, these concerns are either unfounded or unjustly infringe on the rights of gay and lesbian couples. Consequently, there is no reason to prohibit gay or lesbian couples from obtaining custody of children. Proponents of the natural law ideology, a doctrine that states that moral standards that limit behavior are drawn from a natural order of the world, argue that homosexual parents undermine the laws of nature. The argument holds that